I have always admired the securities and derivative plaintiffs’ bar.
I’ve learned from them. Bill Lerach gave the best oral argument I’ve ever seen. Armed with only a stock-price chart plotting key events and a wooden pointer, he delivered an hour-long argument that told a compelling story of fraud. His emphasis on narrative, rather than an overreliance on technical legal points, changed the way I approach motions to dismiss. I tell my clients’ story, emphasizing their good faith and honesty. I don’t rely on technicalities or gotchas.
I’ve fought hard with them. I love the intellectual challenge of developing arguments that answer difficult allegations, and the securities plaintiffs’ bar often puts my colleagues and me to the test. Discovery can be a brawl, sometimes a bare-knuckled one. Pat Coughlin once accused me of giving hand signals to deposition witnesses and even took the accusation to the judge. For the record, I was exonerated.
I’ve marveled at their ingenuity. Three instances stand out:
The so-called emerging firms seized opportunities for lead-plaintiff roles while the larger firms were still consumed with credit-crisis cases, and they have helped drive new-case filings for roughly 15 years.
After Bill Lerach and Mel Weiss retired, many on the defense side wondered who would lead the securities plaintiffs’ bar. Darren Robbins has clearly earned a place on its Mount Rushmore.
And what can I say about the evolution of the derivative plaintiffs’ bar? It is remarkable how its lawyers have transmogrified what were once largely tag-along nuisance cases into matters that sometimes can present real governance questions. They are talented lawyers, creative strategists, and innovative businesspeople. Defense lawyers underestimate them at their peril.
We owe our clients vigorous advocacy. We don’t owe them needless antagonism.
Doug Greene
I’ve befriended them. I enjoy visiting with plaintiffs’ lawyers. Rob Weiser and I have always had good, long conversations. I used to joke that I had to add $50,000 to the budget whenever Rob Weiser was involved. But he is hardly alone. I make time to talk with many plaintiffs’ lawyers, and I value the relationships we have built.
Those relationships are not self-indulgent. My cases go better when my adversary is also my friend. We spend less time and energy on needless disputes. We can put aside posturing, speak candidly about the merits, and trust that the other person is actually listening. We can cut to the chase. We can disagree, even sharply, without it burning energy and credibility.
None of this requires either side to pull its punches. Friendship does not mean compromising a client’s interests, overlooking an argument, or avoiding a fight that needs to be fought. It means reserving the fight for issues that matter. It means extending professional courtesies without keeping score, making realistic requests, and keeping an open mind on contentious issues.
None of this requires either side to pull its punches.
Friendship does not mean
- Compromising a client’s interests
- Overlooking an argument
- Avoiding a fight that needs to be fought
It means
- Reserving the fight for issues that matter
- Extending professional courtesies without keeping score
- Making realistic requests
- Keeping an open mind on contentious issues
That kind of relationship can also make hard cases easier to resolve. Counsel who trust each other can test assumptions, identify the real obstacles to settlement, and have candid conversations that would be impossible if every exchange were treated as tactical warfare. Even when a case is difficult to resolve, cooperation on peripheral matters leaves both sides with more time and credibility to contest the central ones.
I know that the plaintiffs’ lawyers I call friends feel the same way. Yet too many plaintiffs’ and defense lawyers remain at odds over everything, as if reflexive hostility were a measure of commitment to the client. It isn’t. Incivility is expensive, distracting, and strategically unproductive.
We owe our clients vigorous advocacy. We don’t owe them needless antagonism. We would serve them and D&O insurers and brokers better if we worked harder to find common ground, treated one another as worthy adversaries, and even became friends sometimes.

